menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

The Fifth Circuit Got the Law Right. Now Fix the Docket.

20 0
25.10.2026

On Friday, the full Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 10-7 that immigrants who entered illegally and were never admitted can be held without a bond hearing while their removal cases proceed. The ruling covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. I think the court read the law correctly. Detention without bond is defensible only when the hearing that follows arrives quickly, and the system built to deliver those hearings is short of judges.

I studied criminal justice and constitutional law at Northeastern, and as an expert witness, I’ve been deposed and have testified in state and federal courts. I read this opinion twice, once as a citizen and once as someone who has watched what a process is supposed to produce.

The case, Sosnava Rodriguez v. Ortega, involved three men who had lived here since 2011, since 2012 and for more than 22 years without ever being admitted. Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority that the Constitution entitles them to no “additional proceedings beyond what Congress has provided” before they are detained pending removal. Congress did write the rule. Federal law treats anyone present without admission as an applicant for admission, and an applicant who isn’t clearly and beyond a doubt entitled to enter “shall be detained” for removal proceedings.

A bond hearing asks whether a person is a flight risk or a danger to the community while the case proceeds. The removal case, where a judge decides whether the person may stay, goes on separately. The majority also declined........

© Townhall