There was a lot of artificial intelligence about this past week. Some of it the subject of the roundtable; some of it sitting at the roundtable. All of it massively hyped. Depending on who you believe, AI will lead to widespread unemployment or a workers’ paradise of four-day weeks.

There was a lot of artificial intelligence about this week. Credit: Greg Straight

These wildly different visions suggest that assessments of the implications of AI are based on something less than a deep understanding of the technology, its potential and the history of humanity in interacting with new stuff. In the immediate term, the greatest threat posed by AI is the Dunning-Kruger effect.

This cognitive bias, described and named by psychologists David Dunning and Justin Kruger around the turn of the century, observes that people with limited competence in a particular domain are prone to overestimating their own understanding and abilities. It proposes that the reason for this is that they’re unable to appreciate the extent of their own ignorance – they’re not smart enough or skilled enough to recognise what good looks like. As Dunning put it, “not only does their incomplete and misguided knowledge lead them to make mistakes, but those exact same deficits also prevent them from recognising when they are making mistakes and other people are choosing more wisely”.

AI has layers and layers of........

© The Sydney Morning Herald