menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Exams should select, not reject, students

21 0
08.11.2026

Competition is wonderful in sports and in business, where everyone strives to be better and everyone grows. But competition may not be the best way to develop human beings. India , like China , relies on competitive examinations to separate the best in class from the also-rans in engineering, medicine and law. This works beautifully for corporations hunting for talent.

The toppers reach the IITs, AIIMS and National Law Schools, and corporations line up with great packages. Education turns into a race for remuneration. Learning becomes secondary; ranks and CGPA become everything. Our institutions take pride in their selectivity ratio. In truth, it is an elimination ratio. To make the race more rigorous, we added negative marking. In practice, it penalises a student for daring to attempt what she partly knows, and rewards speed over understanding. The outcome? Our best engineering minds often end up in finance, marketing and process management.

One study found about six in ten IIT Bombay B.Tech graduates placed in non-core roles such as consulting and finance. We are creating competition for the best jobs in town, not passion for mastering a subject. I blame this on an examination system that protects the heads of our premier institutions from the hard work of selecting students. A single rank is safe. A judgement made by a teacher can invite litigation and a media trial alleging........

© The Statesman