Pittsburgh’s ‘Green Man’ was a real person – why the legend outlives the facts
Every semester I teach a class called History of Monsters, Aliens and the Supernatural at Penn State. It fills up quickly, because students, like many people, are fascinated by the supernatural.
During the course, students occasionally bring up the western Pennsylvania tradition of the “Green Man.”
As a folklorist, I study the traditions people practice and share in everyday life, from jokes and family recipes to birthday customs and ghost stories.
The story of the Green Man shows how legends and history can tangle – and how each person who retells a legend helps remake it.
What makes a legend a legend
In everyday speech, “legend” often means a story that isn’t true. For folklorists, a legend is a story about something that may have happened in the real world, told as if it could be true but always open to debate.
As Linda Dégh, a prominent Hungarian American folklorist, once put it, “The legend is a legend once it entertains debate about belief. … The sounding of contrary opinions is what makes a legend a legend.”
This is in contrast to myths, for example, which are sacred creation or explanatory stories set before or outside of normal time.
Importantly, myths and legends are not simply false narratives. They contain different kinds of truth, which depend on the perspectives of the people sharing them. Folklorists don’t study such stories in order to disprove them. Our goal is to understand why these stories matter to people.
Legends are distinct from history because........
