menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Sonia Gandhi's Attempt To Rewrite 1984: Army Was Ready, But Congress Failed Sikhs

67 0
11.11.2026

Sonia Gandhi's Attempt To Rewrite 1984: Army Was Ready, But Congress Failed Sikhs

Nov 11, 2026 08:54 am IST

History can be uncomfortable, but that is precisely why it must be confronted, not sanitised through memoirs, selective recollections and convenient explanations.

In her memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, Sonia Gandhi has offered an account of the delay in deploying the Army during the anti-Sikh massacre of November 1984 that deserves to be challenged against the official documentary record. Her suggestion that General AS Vaidya, the then Chief of Army Staff, refrained from mobilising the nearest Army units because they were manned by Sikh soldiers is a particularly troubling attempt to shift attention away from the failure of the Congress government.

She writes: "Although the Chief of Army Staff General A. S. Vaidya had received his orders the same night as the assassination, we heard later that he decided not to mobilise the nearest units because they were manned by Sikh soldiers, a factor that might have exacerbated the situation."

The phrase "we heard later" is revealing. An allegation of such consequence, implicating the professional judgement of the Army Chief during one of independent India's darkest chapters, is being advanced on the basis of what the author says was heard subsequently. There is no reference to a contemporaneous order, official communication or finding of an inquiry establishing that General Vaidya withheld Sikh-manned units for the reason suggested.

There is, however, an official inquiry that examined precisely the question Sonia Gandhi is now attempting to explain away: the Justice Ranganath Misra Commission of Inquiry. Its findings tell a very different story.

At approximately 10.30 am on 31 October 1984, General AS Vaidya directed a brigade from Meerut to move to Delhi. That brigade reached the capital before midnight.

The Commission examined the evidence of Major General JS Jamwal, the General Officer Commanding, Delhi Area. It recorded that the Army's available strength was approximately 6,100 personnel. Of these, 3,000 jawans were available for field duty, while 3,100 were deployed for security arrangements at Teen Murti Bhavan and along the route to Shakti Sthal for the funeral of........

© NDTV