menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Abortion Laws Treat “Viability” as a Bright Line. It Isn’t.

18 0
09.11.2026

In 2021, Kate Dineen was standing in her kitchen in Boston when her doctor told her over Zoom that her son had experienced a catastrophic stroke in utero. There was only a 50 percent chance the baby would survive after birth, with zero chance of a healthy outcome. Dineen was devastated; she’d previously had a miscarriage and anxiously tracked pregnancy milestones. Still, the decision about what to do next was clear to her and her husband, she told me: “We felt motivated to protect our son from what would have been a life of suffering, however brief.”

But Dineen was 33 weeks pregnant, and when she asked her doctor about her options, she learned Massachusetts banned abortion after 24 weeks. That cutoff roughly corresponds with the “viability line,” or the point in pregnancy when the fetus has a good chance of surviving outside the uterus. There were exceptions if her own health was in danger, and for “lethal” fetal diagnoses, but the stroke didn’t qualify. Once the fetus reached “viability,” Dineen says, she became “an incubator in the eyes of the state.”

For decades, abortion opponents have slung around sensational terms like “late term” and “partial birth” in their efforts to block abortion outright. On its face, banning the procedure after fetal viability might appear like the moderate position—after all, people of all political stripes express discomfort with later abortions, and abortions after 20 weeks’ gestation are extremely rare. But viability is an imprecise term, more ambiguous than meets the eye, and one state recently opted to ditch it altogether.

Today,........

© Mother Jones