menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Gaza cannot wait for the Hague verdict

1 0
latest

The ICJ’s genocide judgment against Myanmar offers a vital way to examine Gaza: not by isolating individual incidents, but by confronting the cumulative evidence. As Israel’s military campaign has devastated the territory, the world must stop treating the absence of a final verdict as permission to delay action.

Gaza has become a landscape the world recognises but has somehow failed to confront. Apartment blocks reduced to concrete dust. Hospitals are struggling to function. Streets erased. Families searching through rubble for relatives. Children carrying the remains of childhood in plastic bags. Entire neighbourhoods transformed beyond recognition.

These are not scenes from a dystopian film. They are documented images from a real place, recorded by journalists, medical workers, humanitarian organisations and Palestinians who have kept filming while living through the destruction. The camera has become an unwilling witness to a catastrophe that diplomatic language too often makes sound abstract.

More than 70,000 Palestinians have reportedly been killed. But the scale of Gaza’s devastation cannot be understood through a death toll alone. The destruction of homes, healthcare, water systems, schools and the basic infrastructure of survival raises a deeper question: what happens to a people when the foundations of collective life are systematically dismantled?

More than 70,000 Palestinians have reportedly been killed. But the scale of Gaza’s devastation cannot be understood through a death toll alone. The destruction of homes, healthcare, water systems, schools and the basic infrastructure of survival raises a deeper question: what happens to a people when the foundations of collective life are systematically dismantled?

That question now sits at the heart of South Africa’s genocide case against Israel before the International Court of Justice (ICJ). The Court has not yet delivered a final judgment finding Israel responsible for genocide. But its provisional-measures orders are binding, and the duty to prevent genocide does not begin only when judges deliver their final words.

The world should pay particular attention to what the ICJ said in its 19th November 2026 judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar. Not because Myanmar and Gaza are identical. They are not. The importance lies in how the Court approached the evidence—and what that approach demands of anyone examining Gaza.

The ICJ found Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya. Crucially, it did not formally lower the legal standard for proving genocide. It retained the demanding requirement that, where genocidal intent is inferred from circumstantial evidence, that intent must be the only reasonable inference from the evidence.

What mattered was the Court’s examination of the totality of the record. It did not treat killings, serious bodily and mental harm, sexual violence, discriminatory policies, attacks affecting children and measures intended to prevent births as disconnected events. It examined how the evidence........

© Middle East Monitor