menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

In the Iran war, a tale of old American dilemmas

22 0
15.09.2026

Eight decades ago, US President Harry S Truman faced a decision that would change the nature of warfare forever.

Japan was still fighting after the surrender of Nazi Germany. The US possessed a weapon unlike anything the world had seen. Truman and his advisers had to decide how best to use America’s overwhelming military power to end the war.

Today, Donald Trump faces a different problem. Iran has suffered substantial military damage, but military success has not translated into the decisive political outcome the US seeks.

Japan in 1945 and Iran today are fundamentally different cases. Nor can the atomic bomb of 1945 simply be compared with today’s sophisticated nuclear arsenals.

Yet, there is a common strategic problem: How does a great power turn military superiority into a political outcome? If Washington were pushed into a corner — by the cost of the conflict, the inability to compel Iran’s submission or pressure to demonstrate that American power can still deliver a decisive result — the temptation to consider previously unacceptable options could arise.

Also Read | Trump expects Iran war to end after US midterm elections, says ‘oil prices will come tumbling down’

What would other nuclear powers learn if the nuclear threshold were crossed? The decision-making process........

© hindustantimes