Choking growth
Pakistan has reached a staff-level agreement with the IMF, meaning the economy gets to stay afloat for another six months.
However, behind the superficial macroeconomic stability is only economic stagnation with no real reforms in sight as the government continues to cling to the same distorted policy choices that that have propped up a broken system for many decades.
The slogans have certainly become more progressive, but the intent remains to preserve the status quo at all costs, no matter how damaging it is to the productive sectors and people that actually comprise the economy.
There’s no better example of this than energy policy.
Over the last several months, closed-door promises and public statements have been made at the highest levels that electricity for industry will be brought down to 9 cents/kWh by April 2025. However, April is here, and that ship seems to be sailing in a different direction.
Industrial power tariffs have indeed come down from over 17 cents/kWh in January 2024 to about 12 cents/kWh at present, largely due to negative fuel cost and quarterly adjustments.
However, things are in the danger zone again as February 2025 saw a sizable drop in power consumption, below the reference level. This triggers upward pressure on the QTA, and depending on the March numbers, we could be looking at increasing tariffs again.
There was also hope within some circles that raising gas prices to punitive levels would shift enough captive load to the grid for a sizable reduction through the QTA mechanism.
Gas price for captive was increased to Rs. 3,500/MMBtu, with an additional “grid transition levy” of Rs. 791/MMBtu to increase the cost of gas-fired captive beyond grid electricity tariffs.
The levy itself is fundamentally flawed and deliberately miscalculated, given that at Rs. 3,500/MMBtu, captive generation costs 14-18 cents/kWh — more expensive than grid electricity of ~12 cents/kWh.
The calculation includes glaring errors, including the use of the B-3 peak rate, applicable for only 4 out of 24 hours, instead of a weighted average of peak and off-peak rates. This, along with other factual inaccuracies, is designed to artificially inflate the levy and force a shift to the grid.
However, industries face significant challenges in shifting to the grid. Pakistan’s grid price remains significantly higher than regional benchmarks, which range between 5–9 cents/kWh, and the industry cannot compete internationally with such input cost differentials, especially in something as major as energy.
Moreover, in urban hubs like Karachi, there is not enough physical space for installation of infrastructure to connect captive users with no power connections to the grid. In other areas, such as those served by HESCO, the grid infrastructure is outdated and incapable of supporting large additional industrial loads.
Furthermore, cogeneration captive plants — which utilize the same gas molecules to produce both power and process heat for applications like steam and hot water — offer far........
© Business Recorder
