menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

James Talarico Has the Rarest Political Virtue

28 0
16.11.2026

James Talarico Has the Rarest Political Virtue

Mr. Bruni is a contributing Opinion writer who was on the staff of The Times for more than 25 years.

On the morning after his astonishing 12-point win in one of the most closely watched Senate races in decades, James Talarico, a newly minted Democratic superstar from a newly blue Texas, visited a patch of red. He went on Fox News.

He could have been walking into the lion’s den as a show of mettle or simply to gloat. Before Election Day, he’d been mocked on the network as James “Tala-freak-o,” and here he was, a freaky and fantabulous victor getting the last laugh.

But when I watched his conversation with the anchors Dana Perino and Bill Hemmer, I didn’t get the impression that he was there to celebrate his own triumph. What struck me, as it has over the past year, was Talarico’s reserve and restraint.

He urged people not to listen to him — or any other politician — too closely, because words are easy and actions count more. He not only complimented President Trump on securing the nation’s Southern border, but also eschewed too much talk of prosecuting officials in the Trump administration. “I am not interested in retribution,” he said. He told Texans who hadn’t voted for him that he’d be working hard for them nonetheless.

I might dismiss all of that as pretty blather if it weren’t so consistent with his tone over time. And I wouldn’t linger over it and thrill to it if it didn’t reflect a faint pattern I detected in many Democrats’ successful midterm campaigns. I saw shoots of humility on a political landscape that has been largely barren of it over recent years.

A lack of humility explains a whole lot about our dysfunction and divisiveness, which we won’t repair without a resurgence of it. We’ve been at one another’s throats in part because we’ve been unhumble — and thus unable to acknowledge that there might be good reason for someone’s divergent opinion, that it’s not necessary to win every argument, that the public good matters as much as our private satisfaction and that a healthy democracy requires compromise, forgiveness, grace. We’ve had unhumble governments, and that has intensified partisanship and exacerbated its toll.

It was a kind of arrogance that, perversely, opened the door to Donald Trump — perhaps the most arrogant presidential candidate and then president we’ve ever had. A centerpiece of his pitch to voters in 2016 and then again in 2024 was that an entrenched and snotty political elite thought it knew better than they did, made no effort to understand the feelings and struggles of Americans in the parts of the country between the coasts, and imposed its ideas — about social justice, globalism, gender roles, language and more — in an oppressive, censorious fashion. There was enough truth to that indictment that Trump twice won the presidency.

But while he could call out others’ sanctimony, he couldn’t recognize or purge the nuclear-grade version of it in himself. His self-consumption and self-regard drove his rejection of the 2020 election results, and many of his supporters, with his encouragement, joined his rebellion, to the point of storming the Capitol and bloodying police officers. While their thinking can rightly be labeled conspiratorial, it can just as accurately be called unhumble. They decided that they held the truth, no matter all the proof to the contrary. They couldn’t accept that their preference for one presidential candidate over another could possibly put them in the minority.

Trump, of course, has spent his second term in the presidency elevating his wants and his wounds above anyone and anything else. His tariffs are less a sound economic strategy than a bludgeon with which he can bonk potentates who perturb him. He exhibits more interest in gilding his lair and putting his stamp on monuments than on fulfilling his pledge to ease Americans’ financial anxieties.

Humility? Don’t make me laugh. In his recent interview with Ross Douthat for “60 Minutes,” he conceded that he wouldn’t be able to summon a smidgen of it even if that were the postmortem terms of passage to paradise. He told Douthat that he would refuse to forgive the likes of James Comey, Nancy Pelosi and other leaders who, in his estimation, wronged him.

The lessons of the Democrats’ midterm rout won’t be wholly clear until more time has passed and more evidence gathered, but it seems to me that many voters were rejecting not just Trump’s megalomania and narcissism but many politicians’ failure to step far enough outside their own egos and interests to hear and heed the people they’re supposed to be serving. Democrats flourished because their approach was such a down-to-earth one. Such a practical one. So........

© The New York Times