What We Miss When We Mistake the Virtual for the Actual
A chatbot can imitate a person, saying all the right things to a lonely teenager, but the best part of an actual relationship is missing—fellow feeling, emotions mutually expressed. A machine cannot emit emotion.
Another person alongside us can feel our feelings at a level beyond words. Much does not have to be spoken. There is nuance in the pauses, in moments when our tears start to form and we force them back in or release them. There are gestures—a hand placed lightly on an arm, a grimace from understanding something painful. Two people, speaker and listener, sense each other’s reactions, and a reflexive exchange ensues.
Nothing like this happens with a machine trained to provide a facsimile of presence. The AI persona offers the consolidated words millions of humans have used, an amalgam that sounds........
