How to Define a Genius
Many renowned geniuses showed little promise in their youth but transformed their potential over time.
Genius isn’t merely high IQ; it’s about groundbreaking contributions to a field or understanding.
Genius emerges from harnessing giftedness with education, motivation, and opportunity.
In surveying the landscape of current scientific knowledge about giftedness, I discovered the work of Rena F. Subotnik, an American psychologist and a prominent scholar in giftedness, talent development, and gifted education. Subotnik argues that giftedness should not be thought of simply as possessing an unusually high IQ or an exceptional ability in childhood. Early potential must be transformed through education, opportunity, motivation, and other psychosocial factors into increasingly sophisticated expertise and, in rare cases, eminence (her term for genius).
Notable Geniuses Who Defied Early Expectations
While people like Marie Curry, Mozart, or Picasso were conspicuously gifted as children, most gifted children do not rise to the level of geniuses. Some may become very successful but not geniuses.
The converse is also true. Many children who reach genius status later in life showed little promise in their youth.
Thomas Edison struggled with conventional schooling, while Albert Einstein, despite his early mathematical ability, failed the general portion of the entrance examination to the Swiss Federal Polytechnic at age 16.
William Shakespeare received only the standard grammar-school education until his mid-teens, when he had to quit to help the family financially. Importantly, there is no historical evidence of extraordinary literary precocity in his childhood. Yet he became arguably the greatest playwright who ever lived.
Leonardo da Vinci had even less formal education. Born illegitimate, he was instructed mainly in ordinary spoken and written Italian rather than in Latin and did not study Greek, philosophy, or mathematics available to children of........
