menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

When Neglect Silences Identity Before It Speaks

76 0
30.03.2026

What Are Adverse Childhood Experiences?

Take our Your Mental Health Today Test

Find a therapist near me

Silent withdrawal in class can signal emotional neglect rather than lack of motivation.

Unaddressed neglect may lead adolescents to seek identity in harmful environments.

Behavior labeled as defiance often reflects unresolved emotional pain and disconnection.

Consistent adult presence can begin to restore identity and rebuild trust in neglected youth.

In many classrooms, some students pass through the day quietly and without drawing attention. Their presence feels easy to manage, especially in environments where teachers balance instruction, behavior, and diverse learning needs. Still, experience has taught me that silence deserves attention, and I have learned to pause when a student seems present in body yet distant in every other way.

During my professional work in Bogotá, I began to notice a student who stayed in my thoughts long after the school day ended. Juan Manuel, known as Juanma, did not ask for attention, yet his presence revealed itself through small, repeated details. I noticed his uniform looked neglected, his eyes carried a constant heaviness, and his body seemed tired before the day even started.

Over several days, I paid closer attention. I saw how his backpack remained on the floor, almost as if it held no meaning. I saw how he avoided interaction, remained distant from classmates, and lowered his head during class with increasing frequency. These moments accumulated quietly and formed a pattern that I could not ignore.

Teachers responded when he placed his head on the desk, calling his name and asking him to sit up. Some expressed frustration, while others continued with the lesson without further concern. I listened, yet I felt that something deeper remained unseen. No report followed, no conversation explored his reality, and over time, his behavior became familiar, and familiarity reduced concern.

At........

© Psychology Today