Egg Donation: Is It Private, or a Secret?
Take our Your Mental Health Today Test
Find infertility counseling and support
Privacy and secrecy can overlap, particularly when parents fear judgment from others.
Research supports telling donor-conceived children about their origins early and in age-appropriate ways.
Children may feel burdened when they are asked to keep their conception hidden from others.
When it comes to donor conception, there is an important difference between protecting your privacy and keeping a secret.
A woman I was working with recently voiced that her biggest concern about using an egg donor was disclosure. She worried about how certain family members might react. She anticipated judgment, unwanted opinions, and criticism.
She wasn't questioning whether egg donation was right for her. Rather, she was questioning who needed to know and whether that knowledge could come back to hurt her or her family.
Our work raised two important questions: Whose information is it to share? And what is the difference between privacy and secrecy?
Privacy Is Not the Same as Secrecy
These terms are often used interchangeably, but privacy and secrecy are not necessarily the same thing.
Privacy is about choosing what information to share, with whom and when. Secrecy, on the other hand, often involves deliberately withholding information, sometimes because of shame, fear, or anticipated judgment.
Privacy: “Our child knows how they were conceived, but we don't feel everyone else needs to know.”
Secrecy: “We don't want anyone to know because we're worried they might see our child or our family differently.”
When Privacy and Secrecy Overlap
Take, for example, a woman who decides not to tell her mother-in-law that she used an egg donor. Perhaps their relationship is difficult. Perhaps she knows her mother-in-law has strong........
