Mark Mazower: Antisemitism or anti-Zionism? The new litmus test
Mark Mazower: Antisemitism or anti-Zionism? The new litmus test
"I see no incompatibility between protesting against what has happened in Gaza and protesting against antisemitism. But this correlation no longer comes naturally to the left as it once did."
Mark Mazower is Professor of History at Columbia University in New York, already at the centre of the protests for Palestine and of the subsequent Trumpian repression. He has published On Antisemitism with Einaudi and collaborates with the cultural pages of the Financial Times. We reach him to discuss the implications of the law on antisemitism currently under discussion in the Chamber of Deputies.
How does the question of the so-called “new antisemitism” arise, of Israel as a collective Jew, which overlaps anti-Jewish hatred with anti-Zionism?
The history of antisemitism begins before the Christian era. And it is a history deeply rooted in Europe, above all because of the rise of Christianity and, more generally, the conversion of Europe into a Christian continent, and the fact that Christianity theologically has a very intimate and at the same time deeply ambivalent relationship to the faith from which it sprang.
The concept of antisemitism dates to the end of the nineteenth century; it is part of the era of politics, parties and mass movements. An era in which many sentiments were politicised – also thanks to newspapers –, including the idea that differences existed between races. Jews were among these: antisemitism emerged as an instrument of political mobilisation.
It was a creature of mass politics, which manifested itself through slogans capable of mobilising tens of thousands of people and, eventually, of mobilising states as well so that they would adopt policies in unprecedented ways.
The possibility that a powerful modern state, endowed with industrial capabilities, could be mobilised in the service of such slogans is the legacy we have received: it is the legacy of fascism and Nazism. Post-war Europe defined itself on the basis of this awareness.
The question of “new antisemitism” is what motivated me to write the book. So the book is written out of the experience of seeing, after 7 October 2023, a debate in North American universities that raged around the question of what constituted a legitimate protest against Israel.
The antisemitism of the nineteenth century, that of the beginning of the twentieth century and that of fascism and Nazism consisted in the mobilisation of prejudice against Jews as an ethnic group. It is a period preceding the emergence of Zionism and the creation of a Jewish nation-state.
In the 1960s and 1970s, when I was growing up in London, antisemitism was a matter of prejudice, discrimination or hatred towards Jews. It had little or nothing to do with Israel: the problem was the far right. Today the debate has expanded to include criticism of Israel – a political concept. A paradox emerges: right-wing movements and parties wrapped themselves in the shroud or under the banner of fighting antisemitism on the basis of this new definition of antisemitism. Parties and forces that have an demonstrably antisemitic origin. And so the man in the street feels unbelievably confused, while the fight against anti-Jewish hostility becomes more complicated.
You have written that the IHRA (International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance) definition of 2016 is “indeterminate, repetitive, incomplete”, saying that it “demonstrates the kind of problems that a misconceived approach can cause” and that, ultimately, the examples assume a central role because it is too approximate. Could you explain the construction of the IHRA definition in comparison with the Jerusalem Declaration (2021)?
We live in a golden age of the historiography of antisemitism and scholars have come to a kind of consensus that defining antisemitism was a fool's errand. It didn't add anything, and in fact often it was positively harmful. And precisely then, in the corridors of power of international organisations, a movement arose to obtain international recognition of a definition of antisemitism that turns it into a totem. The totem is the IHRA definition. If you are against the totem, supposedly, you are against the fighting antisemitism. If you're for the totem, supposedly, you're serious about fighting antisemitism. It is therefore not surprising that, after this definition was promulgated, many of the best scholars said that a more serious definition needed to be created: the Jerusalem Declaration.
In the United States or Western Europe between 1945 and 1970, no one felt the need for an official definition. And antisemitism was considered part of the same problem as other types of racism. I know the 1993 Mancino Law and it........
