At present, I am caring for several frail, bedridden older adults through home-based care. Some have advanced dementia. Others have end-stage heart failure, stroke, advanced cancer or multiple organ dysfunction. They are receiving everything modern medicine recommends—appropriate investigations, evidence-based medicines, nutritional support, wound care, pain control, physiotherapy, caregiver education and regular monitoring.Yet their illnesses continue to progress. This is not a failure of medicine. It is the natural course of many diseases. Unfortunately, many families struggle to accept this reality. Perhaps nowhere is this more visible than in Kashmir.

THE QUESTION NOBODY WANTS TO ASKFamilies often ask: “Doctor, what else can we do?” Sometimes they are not asking for treatment. They are asking for hope. Medicine should always offer hope. But hope changes. In the beginning, hope means cure. Later it becomes control of disease. Eventually, for some patients, hope becomes comfort, dignity and freedom from suffering. Understanding when hope changes is one of the hardest lessons in medicine.We are taught to fight disease. But not every battle can be won.

Modern medicine has transformed countless lives. Heart attacks can be opened with angioplasty. Many cancers can be cured. Hip fractures can be replaced. Kidneys can be supported with dialysis. But medicine also has boundaries.A 92-year-old with advanced dementia, severe frailty, recurrent aspiration pneumonia, kidney failure and severe malnutrition is very different from a healthy 65-year-old with early-stage cancer. Their biological reserves are not the same. Their ability to recover is not the same. Treating both patients identically would actually be poor medical practice.

ONE SHOE NEVER FITS EVERY PATIENTPeople often compare treatment between........

© Greater Kashmir