Politic | Democracy Demands Debate, Not Monologues and Marketing
Listen to this article:
A leader who has been accused of smothering democracy is being asked for a public debate. An anti-intellect atmosphere hasn’t been so meticulously created over the decade to ultimately surrender to reason. Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi’s exceptional decision to challenge Prime Minister Narendra Modi to have a public debate is actually a useful ploy to expose the nature of the political project envisioned by the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) which never believed in deliberative democracy.
Rahul Gandhi is intelligent enough to understand the paradox; he knows that Modi would never fight using a legitimate democratic instrument that public debate is, to either run down the opponent or defend his own credentials. He will rather rely on propaganda, falsehood, irrelevant issues, myths and distorted facts of the past, emotional anxieties of the masses and plain lies to mask the reality. Debate is the heart of democracy. Why will a leader undermine democratic culture if he has to solve issues through debates and deliberations?
A leader interested in autocratic control will have to avoid exchange of ideas, sense of accommodation and the commitment to operate within the confines of constitutional scheme. Little wonder, Modi replaced those democratic virtues by monologues, unilateral decision-making and extra-constitutional machinations. His decisions to devalue the Cabinet system, stop addressing press conferences and dodge parliamentary proceedings are manifestations of the same undemocratic syndrome. He is the first and the only prime minister who has not answered any questions at all in Parliament.
While the prime minister has obviously not responded to the Congress leader’s repeated exhortations on his refusal to join the public debate, Union home minister Amit Shah’s sole answer to Gandhi’s dare is – come to parliament and debate every issue! That compels us to recall the miserable plight of parliament over the last few years. While many critical issues are not allowed to be discussed, every word Gandhi speaks triggers wild protests from the ruling party members and ministers. Even the Lok Sabha Speaker does everything to obstruct and derail his speech, finally expunging........
