menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Independence is a skill, not a status

17 0
yesterday

On Israel’s Independence Day, people sing, barbecue, wave flags, and speak about miracles. All of that belongs. A nation should know how to celebrate its survival. Still, celebration can make people sentimental, and sentiment can make them soft in the wrong places. Independence is not a mood. It is a burden. It is a condition that has to be carried by people strong enough to carry it.

That is why Hatikva still matters.

Many anthems are built around triumph. Hatikva is built around endurance. Its emotional center is not victory. It is persistence. “Our hope is not yet lost, the hope that is two-thousand years old, to be a free nation in our land, the land of Zion and Jerusalem.” Those lines are beautiful because they are restrained. They do not beg. They do not boast. They state a national direction that survived exile, humiliation, massacre, and statelessness. They also define the assignment. A free people in its land must be able to remain free in its land. (main.knesset.gov.il)

That last line is where people often stop thinking. They hear “free” and imagine release. They hear “our land” and imagine arrival. History has been much less romantic. To be a free people in your land means that when danger comes, you do not wait for someone else to solve it. You build an army. You build intelligence. You build families that know what they are serving. You build citizens who understand that freedom without readiness is decoration.

The Jewish story should have ended that illusion a long time ago. No people on earth has more historical evidence against dependency. Jews prayed in other people’s countries. Built in other people’s countries. Contributed to other people’s countries. Trusted the rules of other people’s countries. Then history turned, again and again, and reminded them that tolerated weakness is still weakness. An independent state changed that equation because it restored something more important than dignity alone. It restored agency.

Agency is expensive. It asks more from a people than slogans do. It asks them to see reality early, judge it soberly, and respond before the cost becomes catastrophic. That is true in war. It is true in politics. It is true in the street. It is true in the life of a single individual.

This is where the meaning of national independence becomes personal. A state that values sovereignty should also value citizens who can stand on their own feet. If a society celebrates freedom while producing dependency, passivity, and helplessness, it is slowly hollowing out the very thing it claims to honor. That is part of what independence really means. It means responsibility before comfort. It means preparedness before performance. It means accepting that freedom is sustained by people who can act under pressure.

Krav Maga came out of that world. People who reduce it to a collection of techniques miss the point. Its deeper logic is Jewish and Israeli in the most serious sense. It begins with a refusal to outsource survival. It teaches a person to recognize danger honestly, move decisively, absorb stress without collapse, and protect what matters without waiting for permission. Those are fighting skills. They are also civic virtues.

A person who cannot manage fear is not independent. A person who cannot function once pressure enters the room is not independent. A person who speaks constantly about justice, peace, and values but cannot handle violence when it arrives has moral opinions, but very little sovereignty. This is one reason physical training matters far beyond fitness. It teaches reality in a language the body cannot fake. Distance is real. Timing is real. Hesitation is real. The consequence is real.

That is also why mindset is not motivational fluff. Mindset is the structure that decides whether a person freezes, negotiates well, overreacts, under reacts, or moves with control. In a serious self-defense system, mindset is the discipline of facing facts without self-deception. You learn to see what is in front of you. You learn to act without panic. You learn that fear is information, not a verdict. You learn that violence is ugly, fast, and morally costly, which is exactly why preparation matters.

This also sits inside self-defense in Jewish tradition. Jewish ethics never demanded helplessness. They demanded responsibility. A mature moral framework does not worship force, but it does insist on the duty to preserve life. That duty becomes meaningless when it is disconnected from capability. Good intentions do not stop bad actors. Hope by itself does not hold a border. Values by themselves do not pull a child out of danger.

Hatikva is powerful because it is hopeful without being naive. The anthem does not sing about fantasy. It sings about a people that stayed oriented toward freedom for two thousand years and finally returned to history as an actor instead of a subject. That return came with a price. It still does. Israeli independence is defended by young men and women who are asked to carry consequences that many critics discuss from a safe distance. The least serious way to honor that burden is to turn Independence Day into a sentimental ritual emptied of its demand.

The demand is clear. Be worthy of freedom.

For a nation, that means military strength, civic seriousness, internal cohesion, and the moral stamina to defend life without losing its soul. For an individual, it means something just as concrete. Train your body. Sharpen your mind. Build awareness. Build restraint. Build the capacity to protect yourself and others when life stops being theoretical.

A free people in its land cannot afford the fantasy that someone else will always arrive in time. That fantasy has broken Jewish bodies too many times.

Independence is a discipline. Israel exists because enough Jews were willing to accept that truth. It will remain strong only if enough Jews continue to accept it now.

Do something amazing, Tsahi Shemesh


© The Times of Israel (Blogs)