A recent study examining household-level fiscal transfers in Israel has reignited a familiar debate about contribution, dependency, and the distribution of public resources. According to the study, significant disparities exist between what different sectors contribute to the public treasury and what they receive in public services and transfers.

That is not what interests me most.

What surprised me was the reaction—or perhaps more precisely, the absence of one.

The issue is hardly unknown. For years, Israelis have debated military service exemptions, workforce participation, coalition bargaining, and public funding. Reports have been published, warnings have been issued, and election campaigns have repeatedly touched upon the subject.

What is striking, however, is not the absence of discussion but the absence of resolution. The same concerns reappear year after year. New studies are published. New warnings are issued. Yet the underlying trends continue largely unchanged.

One is reminded of the biblical expression, “אֵין פֹּצֶה פֶּה וּמְצַפְצֵף” (“no one raises a voice, no one even chirps”). The phrase originally described a people so........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)