A documented record of hereditary bondage, migrant auctions, kafala, and a Yazidi captive in Gaza—set against a Western vocabulary that reserves “apartheid” for Israel.

Western capitals still treat “apartheid Israel” as settled moral language. Meanwhile, documented slavery and slave-like systems persist in Arab states that are almost never asked to answer for them—and Gaza is part of that record, not an exception to it.

Start with the present, not the seventh century.

Mauritania: hereditary slavery after abolition

Mauritania was the last country on earth to outlaw slavery, in 1981. Parliament only criminalized the practice in 2007. The practice did not end. The BBC, citing Walk Free’s 2023 Global Slavery Index, still put the figure at about 149,000 people enslaved—roughly 3 percent of the population. Field reporting has described the same hereditary system for years; see The Guardian on bondage after formal abolition. UN Watch told the Human Rights Council in 2026 that hereditary bondage of the Haratin continues and that anti-slavery activists are still harassed. The U.S. State Department Trafficking in Persons report records that prosecutions for hereditary slavery remain rare. This is a living hierarchy over Black descendants of the old trans-Saharan trade—not a colonial relic invented in Brussels.

Libya: markets, detention, and a trafficking business model

In 2017, journalists filmed Africans sold at auction in Libya. That was not a closed chapter. A joint UNSMIL–OHCHR report on 2024–2025 describes trafficking, ransom, sexual slavery, and the sale and transfer of migrants as a business model involving armed groups and state-linked actors. The 2025 U.S. Trafficking in Persons report on Libya records thousands of migrants in official and unofficial detention, forced labor, and sex trafficking. Sub-Saharan Africans remain the principal victims. Academic work has described this as a renewed slave trade in Libya, 2015–2024. The Sahara-to-Maghreb route never fully closed; it changed owners.

The Gulf: kafala as legal control over migrant labor

Under kafala, a migrant’s legal existence is tied to a sponsor. The Council on Foreign Relations describes a system that facilitates modern slavery. Human Rights Watch reports that abusive elements remain in Qatar after World Cup labor reforms. The Guardian documented domestic workers across the Gulf whose conditions meet UN trafficking indicators: passport seizure, no exit, violence, unpaid labor. Walk Free ranked Saudi Arabia first in the Arab region for estimated people in modern slavery. Rights groups continue to describe Gulf sponsorship rules as structurally exploitative. This is not ordinary wage bargaining. It is a legal architecture of control over foreign labor, including large African and Asian workforces.

Gaza: residue of the trade, trafficking, and one documented captive

Gaza is not running open desert caravans from the Maghreb. Claiming that would be false. What is documented is different, and still damning.

Afro-Palestinians—many descended from Africans owned by Negev and Gaza Bedouin, or brought........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)