The Courage to Bless Even ‘Smelly’ Opinions
Parashat Tetzaveh is, at first glance, a choreography of details. Measurements. Fabrics. Precious stones. Oil. Fire. Fragrance. The Torah lingers over the priestly garments, the breastplate set with twelve stones, the daily offerings, and the sacred incense. “And you shall make holy garments for Aaron your brother, for glory and for beauty” (Exodus 28:2). Nothing is left to improvisation. Sight, sound, touch, even smell, are enlisted into a total spiritual experience. The Mishkan is not only constructed; it is curated. And then there is the incense.
The Torah commands: “Take for yourself spices- stacte, onycha, galbanum, and pure frankincense; they shall be in equal measure” (Exodus 30:34). Rabbinic tradition expands this into the well-known Pitom HaKetoret: eleven ingredients blended with exquisite precision. Among them is chelbenah, galbanum, a resin with a pungent, even foul odor. Which raises an obvious question: Why include something that smells bad in a mixture designed to rise heavenward as a “pleasing aroma before the Lord” (Exodus 30:7)?
The Sages notice the tension and lean into it. In the Talmud we read: “Any fast in which the sinners of Israel do not participate is not a true fast” (Keritot 6b). The galbanum, they teach, symbolizes those in the community whose deeds, or perhaps whose opinions, offend us. And yet, without them, the incense is invalid. Incomplete. Disqualified. The sacred........
