I have spent the better part of twenty years doing something that should, in any functioning state, be entirely unremarkable. I have been asking for electricity data.

Not secrets. Not classified intelligence. Not the kind of information that spy agencies bury in vaults. I have been asking for the operational data of Pakistan's electricity sector, generation figures, capacity utilisation, independent power producer contract details, fuel costs, load factors, the basic numerical record of an industry that consumes billions of dollars of public money every year and sends an electricity bill to every household in the country. I work at Apex Accountability, where accountability without data is simply a word. And for twenty years, Pakistan's power sector has looked me in the eye and said, in effect: you are not entitled to know.

I once raised this directly with the Chairman of the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority and the Managing Director of the Private Power and Infrastructure Board. I asked why the data of a public utility, funded by public money and regulated in the public interest, was being protected with the ferocity normally reserved for a pharmaceutical patent or a military secret.

The response, delivered with bureaucratic composure, was effectively this: the data was sensitive, its release required process, and the complete picture was never fully digitised anyway. What they were describing, without using the word, was omertà. The absolute code of silence that the Italian Mafia perfected over generations, where information is power, power is money, and the first rule of the institution is that outsiders never see the books. The Mafia, at least, has the honesty to admit it is a criminal enterprise.

I say this not in bitterness but in the exhaustion of a man who has watched his country's most critical sector operate for two decades as a zero-knowledge architecture a system designed so that even its own regulator cannot tell you with confidence how much electricity the country actually produces, how much it wastes, how much it pays for capacity that sits idle, and how much of the consumer's bill is pure extraction dressed in the language of regulation.

And then,........

© The Friday Times