menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Mid-Air Birth Flies Home How Stupid Birthright Citizenship Is

33 0
08.04.2026

1 Trending: Artemis II Mission Shows There Are No Limits To American Exceptionalism

2 Trending: California Is Trying To Save The Pediatric Trans Industry Because It’s Dying

3 Trending: Russia Hoaxer And CCP Patsy Eric Swalwell Accused Of Sexual Harassment, Misusing Funds

4 Trending: ‘Zuckbucks’ Cities’ Ballot Blunders Hit Badger State Election Day

Mid-Air Birth Flies Home How Stupid Birthright Citizenship Is

The extreme manipulation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Citizenship Clause must end now if the republic is to survive.

Share Article on Facebook

Share Article on Twitter

Share Article on Truth Social

Share Article via Email

To borrow from comedian Jeff Foxworthy’s famous redneck schtick, if you were born on a flight over U.S. air space, you might be a U.S. citizen. 

The latest birthplace debate underscores just how insanely stupid sweeping birthright citizenship has become in the modern age. And it’s another example of why the U.S. Supreme Court needs to fix a flawed 130-year-old interpretation of the Constitution. 

‘A Child Born on a Plane’

Multiple corporate outlets had some fun reporting on the “stork” story of a passenger who gave birth over the weekend during a flight from Jamaica to New York City.  The Caribbean Airlines flight “landed at New York’s John F. Kennedy international airport with one more person than it took off with,” the liberal Guardian guffawed.

As the cheeky piece explained, the citizenship status of the newborn remained up in the air because officials had yet to make clear the citizenship status of the parents — “and where the plane was at the exact moment the baby was born.” The child would, of course, automatically be a U.S. citizen if either parent is a U.S. citizen. If not, it depends on precisely where the birth occurred. If the answer is within 12 nautical miles of the U.S. coastline, the newborn just won the U.S. citizenship lottery. 

“… [A] child born on a plane in the United States or flying over its territory would acquire United States citizenship at birth,” the State Department’s rule states. 

All of this drives home the point that the expansive view of birthright citizenship is a bastardization of the law — and it needs to end. This Supreme Court has a chance to bring sanity to more than a century of manipulation of the 14th Amendment’s Citizenship Clause, twisted to appease myriad monied interests. 

‘Wherein They Reside’

Last week,........

© The Federalist