menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Tax reform and defiant untaxed bazaar

51 0
previous day

Pakistan's tax administration remains formidable where incomes are visible and hesitant where organised power resists scrutiny. Another disappointing retail scheme exposes that imbalance. Reform cannot mean repeatedly asking compliant businesses to finance the state while influential traders negotiate their obligations.

The latest reporting identifies only 1,750 scheme participants against 3.6 million potential retail nonfilers, including merely 220 fresh filers. That means participation below 0.05 per cent and fresh filing near 0.006 per cent. These are measures of a scheme's reach, not proof that every nonfiler owes tax.

The revenue chronology also matters. Reported first quarter receipts exceeded the aggregate target; October subsequently exposed weakness. Provisional estimate, as reported in this newspaper on October 31, put the July–October shortfall at Rs124 billion, while subsequent reporting put the figure at Rs129 billion and finally another source says it is Rs96 billion. The distinction matters when evaluating what revenue performance reveals........

© The Express Tribune