America Needs to Reckon With What Trump 2.0 Has Done. Planning Should Start Now.
Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.
A reckoning is coming for the Trump administration. Rising numbers of Americans want accountability for all the crimes, corruption, and cruelties committed by the Trump administration since January 2025. One poll has suggested that a whopping 77 percent of Democrats believe criminal prosecution of administration officials is warranted for actions that range from their military strikes to Immigration and Customs Enforcement attacks on citizens. Democrats must be hearing these demands from voters regularly, as many—including centrists like Sen. Elissa Slotkin—are promising robust oversight if they take Congress in the November midterms. That’s good, and it makes accountability an issue for the upcoming midterms. But we also need a long-term vision of how accountability fits into American democracy, with an appeal to those across the political spectrum. The planning should start now.
It will be a long road ahead. For one thing, Americans are skeptical. A recent Gallup poll found that a majority of Americans lack trust that their leaders will ever be held accountable under U.S. law. After two failed impeachments of Donald Trump and the Supreme Court’s determination in Trump v. United States that presidents enjoy immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts, that view is understandable. Even so, the public appetite for a government that can hold politicians accountable for illegal acts appears to be growing. A raft of new books on political and elite impunity—like End Times Fascism by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor, The Nerd Reich by Gil Duran, and Profiles in Cowardice by Jacob Weisberg—are storming the bestseller list, signaling a simmering anger about the law’s inequities and the dangers to democracy. Meanwhile, some of Trump’s staunchest rank-and-file supporters are going quiet.
Americans are right to demand an end to impunity. We have never had an administration that has committed so many crimes and so much corruption at home and abroad. It has disobeyed court orders, shuttered federal agencies without any basis in law, repressed freedom of expression, pursued vindictive prosecutions against perceived political enemies, assaulted our cities and peaceful protesters, caused lasting damage to the global economy and global health, undermined international institutions, and failed to comply with a range of American laws touching on the environment, education, climate, and public health. Trump, his family, and his associates have engaged in self-dealing at a level never seen at this scale in American history. All the while, the administration has sought to crush the pillars of democratic civil society, such as independent journalism, colleges and universities, social sciences, and the legal profession.
Congressional oversight will have to be the first part of the accountability agenda, but its path will be bumpy and less effective than promoters may hope. Needless to say, this ideally should start with Americans first electing a Congress next month that will pursue oversight. Yet even........
