menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

The Supreme Court Gave Trump Impunity. Congress Has the Chance to Do the Funniest Thing.

13 0
09.11.2026

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

Last week ushered in an electoral sea change in the United States, with Democrats and democracy sweeping to unexpected victories nationwide. But election returns represent a single day and massive democratic repairs are the stuff of years. The real work, to be sure, begins now. On this week’s Amicus podcast, Dahlia Lithwick spoke to Ian Bassin of Protect Democracy. Bassin served as associate White House counsel during the Obama administration. Along with a handful of other former administration lawyers, he founded Protect Democracy in late November of 2016 to prevent American democracy from declining into an authoritarian form of government. He’s been a stalwart voice for democratic revival and repair over his years on the podcast. A portion of their conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity below.

Dahlia Lithwick: Everyone and their mom and their cat is making proclamations about what the Dems have to do right now, the second they’re sworn in. What are the things we need to do in terms of immediate repair?

Ian Bassin: I think that there’s a couple of things that are going to be on the immediate agenda. Exit polls showed there is public outrage about corruption, and that corruption drove so much of this voting behavior. The Democrats now have the opportunity in Congress to serve as a check against it.

I don’t think voters are just going to want hearings for hearings’ sake. They don’t want subpoenas and “lawyer up” for subpoenas’ and lawyer up’s sake. The purpose of oversight generally is to expose corrupt behavior so that voters can then respond to it. The corrupt behavior is known, the voters responded to it. So now, what those oversight committees need to do is go get the money back. Because what we’ve witnessed over the last two years is just a splurge of corruption and a splurge of the president and his family and his allies enriching themselves at the expense of American taxpayers unlike anything we’ve seen in U.S. history, and the American taxpayers are entitled to get that money back.

The misguided Supreme Court decision in Trump v. U.S. basically shielded the president with this bizarre form of immunity that exists nowhere in the Constitution—meaning it’s very unlikely you’re going to see something like a Jack Smith–type criminal prosecution in the future. The president’s already said he’s going to pardon everybody on the way out the door. So let’s set criminal accountability aside for a minute. What pardons and criminal immunity cannot do is they cannot protect those ill-gotten gains from unjust enrichment claims brought by a future attorney general. They cannot protect ill-gotten gains from civil asset forfeiture claims brought by a future attorney general.

A future attorney general who wants to go get the American taxpayers’ money back from where it’s been stolen can do so. The key, I think, for the oversight committees will be to really preserve a record of where all that money went. We’re talking about billions of dollars that have been stolen in corrupt ways from the American people, or stolen based on the improper use of public office. The House Oversight Committee and the Judiciary Committee need to........

© Slate