Yes or no? Here are the Chronicle’s endorsements for California Supreme Court and appeals courts
Every four years, California voters are given the important yet perplexing job of deciding whether to retain a slate of judges who already serve on the state Supreme Court and district appeals courts.
The November ballot lists the names of each judge up for retention and asks the voters to mark “yes” or “no.” A yes will give the candidate an additional 12-year term on top of the time they have already served or allow them to finish out the unexpired remainder of a predecessor’s unfinished term. State law requires that judges appointed by the governor must run to be retained “in the first such election at which there was sufficient time for the appointee to file papers.”
Chronicle endorsements: Editorial Board’s recommendations for 2026 election
It’s confusing, to be sure. But given the crucial role that the judiciary has played in slowing the Trump administration’s assault on states like California that did not support him in the 2024 election, one might think that judicial retention elections would receive equal or greater attention and scrutiny than some other down-ballot races.
Article continues below this ad
In fact, most voters have never heard of the judges whose tenure they are being asked whether to extend. That’s primarily because those who sit on the California Supreme Court and the state’s district appeals courts are nominated by the governor, and the exhaustive vetting process used to select candidates largely takes place out of public view.
Prospective candidates must submit a list of 50 to 75 references who can attest to their professional ability, judicial temperament and personal character. The Commission on Judicial Nominees Evaluation then contacts hundreds of people — from lawyers to professors to judges — and conducts extensive interviews with the judicial candidate before rating each candidate. The goal is to establish, among other things, a judge’s impartiality, intellectual capacity and professional experience. The committee makes a report at a........
