Endorsement: ‘When everyone is in charge, no one is in charge.’ Yes on S.F.’s Prop F
Most San Franciscans know their city has a “strong mayor” system of governance. But what does that actually mean?
A strong mayor is the chief executive — responsible for managing the departments that keep a city running. This type of mayor sits opposite an independent legislative body— in San Francisco’s case, the Board of Supervisors — which writes ordinances the mayor can veto.
Within this general rubric, however, quirks can exist; San Francisco has many.
In 2024, local think tank SPUR produced an exhaustive report on the ways San Francisco’s City Charter kneecaps its strong mayor system.
Article continues below this ad
A charter is a city’s constitution; it should set broad roles and responsibilities. But San Francisco’s charter has accumulated so much organizational detail that about 90% of city departments the mayor is supposed to manage are effectively solidified in amber. The city’s 43 department heads are required to report directly to the mayor, an unreasonable and unmanageable number. And the mayor has limited authority to hire and fire those reports or reorganize departments to make government run more efficiently.
Proposition F is a charter amendment from Mayor Daniel Lurie on the November ballot that would implement many of SPUR’s reform recommendations.
The measure would take most hiring and firing decisions for department heads from independent commissions and give them to the mayor. It would also let the mayor delegate supervision of department heads to deputy mayors — and reorganize or consolidate departmental........
