Many workers break rules to help customers. Their bosses punish them anyway
Get Quartz in your inbox
Free daily briefing on global business news.
Many workers break rules to help customers. Their bosses punish them anyway
Most managers punish everyone the same way for breaking a rule. Employees step out of line for four reasons, and only one is personal gain
Ivan Pantic / Getty Images
A version of this article originally appeared in Quartz’s Leadership newsletter. Sign up here to get the latest leadership news and insights straight to your inbox.
Plenty of managers write up an employee as soon as they find out he or she broke a rule. They handle every case the same way because it seems fair, and they want the rest of the team to see that nobody gets a pass. And many of them assume the worker was only looking out for himself or herself.
Some employees do put themselves first. Others bend a rule to help a customer, cave to pressure from coworkers or a deadline, or follow their profession's ethics over a company policy, according to a review of more than 250 studies by Oxford's Michael Gill. Gill has watched a lot of managers treat all four kinds of employee alike.
"If your first move is to punish someone, you may be solving the immediate issue but missing the real cause," Gill told Harvard Business Review. "And that can hurt the business in the long term." Once the boss files the write-up, he or she never hears what the employee was trying to do. He or she also never learns whether others on the team have been making the same call for the same reason.
Bosses often punish their most helpful staff
Front-line workers will often bend a company rule to help a customer. In........
