How 'deep links' journalism fuels pointless China panic
A former MP takes on a routine lobbying role, a Chinese university is named, and suddenly we are in national security territory. This is framing doing the work that facts do not.
The Canberra Times has delivered a remarkable feat with its recent report: “_Former Liberal MP lobbying for Chinese university with 'deep links' to People's Liberation Army_” turning a routine post political lobbying gig into the opening act of a national security thriller.
Former Liberal MP Pat Farmer, we’re solemnly informed, is working with a Chinese university that has “deep links” to the PLA. Within three paragraphs, he’s gone from marathon runner to potential Bond villain — albeit one whose alleged plot involves offshore campuses and education policy.
And then, in the fine print, came the ultimate punchline: “there is no suggestion” he’s done anything wrong.
What a useful disclaimer, once readers have already been escorted to the edge of panic.
The article rounds off by listing other former politicians who’ve worked with Chinese-linked firms — Robb, Downer, Brumby — but singles out Farmer as “one of the few advising directly for Chinese government-owned entities.” That’s basically the same thing: all Chinese public universities are state-owned. But it sounds alarming enough to stand.
What makes this specimen of journalism so instructive is the........





















Toi Staff
Gideon Levy
Sabine Sterk
Stefano Lusa
Tarik Cyril Amar
John Nosta
Ellen Ginsberg Simon
Gilles Touboul
Mark Travers Ph.d
Daniel Orenstein