US News Metro Long Island Politics

Sports NFL MLB Olympics NBA NHL College Football College Basketball WNBA

Business Personal Finance

Entertainment TV Movies Music Celebrities Awards Theater

Lifestyle Weird But True Sex & Relationships Viral Trends Human Interest Parenting Fashion & Beauty Food & Drink Travel

Health Wellness Fitness Health Care Medicine Men’s Health Women’s Health Mental Health Nutrition

Science Space Environment Wildlife Archaeology

Today’s Paper Covers Columnists Horoscopes Crosswords & Games Sports Odds Podcasts Careers

Email Newsletters Official Store Home Delivery Tips

Switch between CA and NY editions here.

Kids have free speech, even in California— and, yes, ‘all lives matter’

That should not be a controversial statement, nor should the phrase “any life matters.”

Unfortunately, in our divided nation, some on the left consider “all lives matter” a challenge to the slogan “Black Lives Matter.”

If you say “all lives matter,” you risk offending the PC police.

It’s confusing enough for adults — never mind for 6-year-old children.

Yet a 6-year-old girl at Viejo Elementary School in San Juan Capistrano was disciplined for writing “any life” on a “Black Lives Matter” drawing that she gave to a black classmate in an innocent gesture of solidarity.

That classmate’s mother emailed the school, which allegedly took action against the 6-year-old girl.

The girl’s mother sued the school, claiming that it had violated the child’s First Amendment rights.

District Court Judge David O. Carter — notorious for his left-wing activism — granted the school’s motion to throw out the case, saying that the drawing was not protected by the First Amendment.

A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit — two judges appointed by Joe Biden, and one by George W. Bush — disagreed.

They ruled unanimously that even young children have First Amendment rights.

Speech can be restricted only if it is disruptive to the school or threatens other students. 

Writing “any life” on a “Black Lives Matter” drawing — made by the student herself — does not qualify as a threat.

This may appear to be a small case, but it goes to the core of free speech.

“All lives matter” is not an inherently offensive phrase. It simply states a moral truth that we all should acknowledge.

In this case, the person who was offended was not the girl’s classmate, but the mother of that classmate.

Download The California Post App, follow us on social, and subscribe to our newsletters

California Post News: Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X, YouTube, WhatsApp, LinkedInCalifornia Post Sports Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, XCalifornia Post Opinion California Post Newsletters: Sign up here!California Post App: Download here!Home delivery: Sign up here!Page Six Hollywood: Sign up here!

An adult brought politics into a friendship among children, and ultimately into the classroom.

We do our kids a great disservice if we encourage them to believe that “all lives matter” is some kind of threat. 

We are also teaching them the wrong lessons if we treat differences of opinion as dangerous.

Words do matter, and we should choose them carefully, for the sake of civility. Yet the fact that someone might take offense does not give her the right to shut down the speech of others.

Had the lower court ruling stood, it might have strengthened the “crybullies” in schools and universities — those students who bully others by claiming victimhood. 

Even the liberal Ninth Circuit has had enough.

Trending Now on NYPost.com

This story has been shared 57,089 times. 57,089 US obliterates ‘every MILITARY target’ on Iran’s oil-critical Kharg Island in historic bombing raid, Trump says

US obliterates ‘every MILITARY target’ on Iran’s oil-critical Kharg Island in historic bombing raid, Trump says

This story has been shared 51,593 times. 51,593 Ferry worker fired from job after taking 114 sick days in 12 months

Ferry worker fired from job after taking 114 sick days in 12 months

This story has been shared 40,140 times. 40,140 Extreme Mamdani estate tax proposal goes right after New York's middle class families

Extreme Mamdani estate tax proposal goes right after New York's middle class families

Rich Lowry Trump is obliterating Obama's Iran-appeasement plan — to America's benefit

Trump is obliterating Obama's Iran-appeasement plan — to America's benefit

Kirsten Fleming The Oscars Ozempic parade is upon us — but is anyone brave enough to tell these sickly stars how they really look?

The Oscars Ozempic parade is upon us — but is anyone brave enough to tell these sickly stars how they really look?

Douglas Murray Trump's decision to fight Iran is historic -- but he needs to finish the job

Trump's decision to fight Iran is historic -- but he needs to finish the job

Cindy Crawford roasted over morning routine: 'Nothing like having money'

Stream It Or Skip It: 'Scarpetta' On Prime Video, Where Nicole Kidman Is A Medical Examiner Who Is Haunted By Serial Killings She Thought She Solved Two Decades Ago

Ferry worker fired from job after taking 114 sick days in 12 months

Sections & Features US News Metro World News Sports Sports Betting Business Opinion Entertainment Fashion & Beauty Shopping Lifestyle Real Estate Media Tech Science Health Travel Astrology Video Photos Alexa Covers Horoscopes Sports Odds Podcasts Crosswords & Games Columnists Classifieds

Post Sports+ Subscribe Articles Manage

Newsletters & Feeds Email Newsletters RSS Feeds NY Post Official Store Home Delivery Subscribe Manage Subscription Delivery Help

NY Post Official Store

Home Delivery Subscribe Manage Subscription

Help/Support About New York Post Editorial Standards New York Post Awards & Recognition Customer Service Apps Help Community Guidelines Contact Us Tips Newsroom Letters to the Editor Licensing & Reprints Careers Vulnerability Disclosure Program

New York Post Awards & Recognition

Contact Us Tips Newsroom Letters to the Editor Licensing & Reprints Careers Vulnerability Disclosure Program

Letters to the Editor

Vulnerability Disclosure Program

Apps iPhone App iPad App Android Phone Android Tablet

Advertise Media Kit Contact

© New York Post