Abu Dhabi: Moscow Held Its Ground. What Is Europe Waiting For?
Abu Dhabi: Moscow Held Its Ground. What Is Europe Waiting For?
Despite their significant financial and military contributions to supporting Ukraine, European countries, by proposing to postpone discussion on the formation of a new security system for the continent, found themselves on the margins of negotiations; Russia and the US, by contrast, continued their own dialogue.
Europe has become Ukraine’s leading source of financial and military support as the Trump administration has cut back direct American aid. Kiev wanted its European partners in the talks, and Washington backed their participation. None of that secured them a meeting with Moscow. European governments have taken on a growing share of the cost. How did they come to have so little influence over the negotiations that are supposed to bring the war to an end?
What Moscow Had Already Put in Writing
Russia and Ukraine came away from two days of talks with an agreement in principle on a large exchange of prisoners of war. For the families waiting for someone to come home, that was reason enough to hold the talks. On the Donbas, the delegations left much as they had arrived. Moscow continued to demand the whole region, including territory still held by Ukraine. Kiev refused to give it up. Vladimir Medinsky, Russia’s chief negotiator, also ruled out a territorial swap.
The dispute over Ukraine’s military alignment has a longer history, and European governments have had the Russian position in writing for years. On December 17, 2021, Moscow published a draft agreement with NATO. A European minister wanting to know where Russia stood on Ukrainian membership had only to turn to Article 6. It called on NATO members to rule out further enlargement and named Ukraine explicitly. The draft could hardly have been clearer about the importance Moscow attached to the question before February 2022.
Nearly five years later, American negotiators are exploring what postwar security guarantees might look........
