menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

FATA – the forever frontier

25 0
08.11.2026

In August 2025, elders from Bajaur and Mohmand rejected military operations and forced displacement and called for an empowered jarga of federal, provincial and tribal representatives to pursue a lasting end to terrorism.

In October 2025, a Grand Aman Jarga in Peshawar demanded dialogue over new operations, consultation with tribal representatives before any federal decision on the merged districts, and release of the funds owed to them.

In June 2025, a federal committee began exploring the revival of the jarga system in the merged districts; the KP government called it a constitutional violation, even as its convenor denied any plan to reverse the merger.

Born around the turn of the millennium, a generation in the former Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) has known little besides war, operations and displacement. The 2018 merger of FATA with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) was presented as the end of that story. This essay argues otherwise. The merger was new wine poured into an old bottle: a genuine constitutional reform placed inside an administrative and strategic vessel that the state never chose to break. As the biblical proverb warns, the old vessel could not hold it.

The vessel was imperial by design. The British governed the tribal belt through the Frontier Crimes Regulation of 1901, which punished whole families and tribes for an individual’s offence and denied those convicted by a jarga any appeal in court. The historian Benjamin Hopkins calls this “frontier governmentality”: peoples were kept outside the state’s courts, made economically dependent while denied access to its economy, and governed through invented “customs” that gave the illusion of self-rule. Pakistan did not dismantle this order; it inherited it. Under Article 247, FATA lay beyond the superior courts and Parliament, administered by the Governor as the President’s agent through Political Agents. Ordinary residents gained the vote only in 1997, when the right ceased to belong to malaks alone, and political parties could operate lawfully only from 2011. For most of a century, the tribal citizen was shut out........

© Minute Mirror