The AI Hiring Arms Race Is Putting the Wrong People in Jobs
The search for a job has turned into a lottery, and artificial intelligence is giving both sides the tickets.
After spending 40 years watching recruitment evolve, the latest transformation worries me more than anything that has come before. We are building a system in which candidates use AI to present themselves as the ideal employee, while employers use AI to identify the ideal candidate.
Each side is becoming better at manipulating the other's technology, and the person who actually deserves the job risks getting lost between the two.
The numbers suggest this is already happening. Greenhouse's 2026 Candidate AI Interview Report found that 63% of job seekers had experienced an AI interview, up 13 percentage points in six months. Yet 70% of those interviewed said they had not been clearly told beforehand that AI would evaluate them. We are automating one of the most consequential decisions in a person's life while leaving many of the people affected uncertain about how it works.
The public debate tends to focus on whether a machine should read someone's CV. I think we are asking the wrong question. Human recruiters have always worked under constraints. Give an employer 2,000 applications and limited time, and some CVs will receive little more than a cursory glance. I remember applying for jobs decades ago and seeing applications dismissed through arbitrary shortcuts. Human involvement has never guaranteed careful consideration, impartiality, or even basic consistency.
So why do we assume that putting a human back into the process automatically makes it fair?
Human judgment carries its own baggage. The halo effect, familiarity bias, and unconscious preferences influence how we assess people, often without our knowledge. I have spent much of my career confronting the halo........
