menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

First Them, Then Us: America’s Shift From Police State To Prison State – OpEd

20 0
03.10.2026

The column argues the immigration crackdown is a crisis playbook—threat, emergency, expanded power—and cites a 2026 Cato Census analysis that legal and undocumented immigrants are less crime-prone than the native-born.

Its core claim is that ICE find-track-detain tools are a dress rehearsal: if non-citizens lose due process, citizens can be redefined out of it, with habeas (Article I, Section 9) as the check dating to Magna Carta.

The wider warning is a surveillance prison state—movement, face, and associations as data—drawn from Snyder and Sinclair Lewis, not a finding that citizens are already being disappeared.

America, you got fooled. Again.

For starters, the war on illegal immigration was never just about illegal immigration.

If you fell for that, chances are you’re still falling for the government’s oldest trick: manufacture a crisis, identify an enemy, frighten the public, declare an emergency, and then use the resulting fear to justify another expansion of government power.

Terrorism. Crime. Drugs. National security. Illegal immigration.

Different threats. Same playbook.

Take a legitimate problem—or inflate it into an existential menace—and suddenly constitutional safeguards become inconveniences, extraordinary powers become necessities, and anyone who questions the government’s methods can be accused of siding with the enemy.

Immigration is a perfect example.

A highly charged issue that pushes all of the knee-jerk, polarizing buttons when it comes to deep-seated fears and prejudices, immigration has been the perfect vehicle for the Trump administration’s political fearmongering and authoritarian power grabs.

Trump has repeatedly described illegal immigration in the language of invasion, criminality and national-security emergency.

Yet a closer look suggests a far more complicated reality.

A 2026 Cato Institute analysis of Census data found that both legal........

© Eurasia Review