menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

A Radically New History Of The Ancient World That Challenges Modern Chauvinism – Book Review

4 0
previous day

Interconnected Origins of the West: Josephine Quinn argues that “Western civilization” emerged not solely from Greece and Rome but through continuous cultural, technological, and intellectual exchanges among Africa, Asia, and Europe over 4,000 years, involving trade networks (Silk Road, Indian Ocean, Mediterranean) and contributions from Islamic, African, Indian, and Chinese civilizations.

Evidence of Early Globalization: Archaeological and historical evidence shows extensive long-distance trade and cultural diffusion as early as the Bronze Age (e.g., Welsh copper, Baltic amber, Phoenician expansion, Roman-Egyptian links to India), demonstrating that the Mediterranean and Eurasian worlds were already highly interconnected long before the European Renaissance or Age of Exploration.

Challenge to Western Exceptionalism: The book contests the traditional narrative of unique Western superiority by showing that key elements of Western culture, science, and institutions were shaped by cross-cultural adoption and adaptation; the modern concept of “the West” itself only solidified in the 19th century.

In “How the World Made the West: A 4,000 Year History“, Josephine Quinn argues that Western civilization emerged from long-standing cultural exchanges between Africa, Asia, and Europe—rather than being merely a product of Greece and Rome—, as we were traditionally taught in school. According to Quinn, the West developed out of a rich array of cultural interactions spanning Europe, Asia, and Africa. These exchanges introduced new technologies, scientific knowledge, and religious ideas to the West—particularly during the Islamic Golden Age and through trade networks such as the Silk Road and the quest to reach India—and contributed to the shaping of the European Renaissance by spreading advances in astronomy, medicine, and mathematics.

Josephine Quinn is Professor of Ancient History at the University of Cambridge, the first woman to hold this chair. She holds degrees from Oxford and the University of California, Berkeley, has taught in the United States, Italy, and Oxford, and was co-director of the Tunisian-British archaeological excavations at Utica.

Even more so than in Howard French’s book “Born in Blackness. Africa, Africans, and the Making of the Modern World. 1471 to the Second World War” (reviewed here) or João Paulo Oliveira e Costa’s “Henrique, o precursor da globalização” (see here), Josephine Quinn challenges our Western conception of history.

She demonstrates how ideas, technologies, and institutions labeled as “Western” emerged through continuous interactions and the adoption of elements from diverse cultures. In doing so, Quinn traces the interconnected networks of trade, the exchange of ideas, and the cross-pollination of customs among civilizations spanning from the Bronze Age to the Middle Ages. As empires rose and fell, diverse societies influenced one another through technology, religion, artistic styles, and political systems, thereby contributing to what we now regard as the Western world.

According to Quinn, “Western civilization” would not exist without its Islamic, African, Indian, and Chinese influences. To understand why, she looks back in time, starting with the bustling port city of Byblos in Lebanon around 2000 BCE. It was the height of the Bronze Age, a period that “ushered in........

© Eurasia Review