Revisiting and Resharing the Idea of an Integrated Justice Approach to Land Reform
*Originally published in 2025 and preserved as part of our archive project.Get E-International Relations delivered directly to your inbox, free of charge. As you sign up, consider becoming a paid subscriber to support our work.
The concept of an integrated justice approach to land reform aims to understand better and address agrarian concerns, particularly where gender justice is often overlooked by key actors, including the state, social movements, and even feminist organisations, in the context of land reform. This approach was developed by building on Fraser’s three-dimensional justice approach (1999, 2005). The concept was first introduced in my PhD manuscript (Bejeno 2021) and later developed in a working paper published by the International Institute of Social Studies (ISS) in October 2021 (Bejeno 2021).
Nearly four years later, I believe it is essential to revisit and expand on the idea, aiming to share it with a broader audience and sparking further conversation around the persistent issue of land injustice in the Philippines—and potentially beyond. This study examines the enduring problem of unjust land (re)distribution through two case studies in the Philippines. The core argument is that land injustices rooted in class and gender are deeply intertwined and shaped by economic maldistribution, cultural misrecognition, and political misrepresentation. As such, any meaningful response to the land reform question must integrate these three dimensions—economic, cultural, and political, or referred to here as the “integrated justice approach to land reform.”
This framework is especially relevant in the Philippine context, and possibly elsewhere, where agrarian structures remain marked by landlord violence, weak political will among reform implementers, and deeply entrenched gender norms. Addressing these challenges requires not just policy reform but a rethinking of justice itself.
Concept of Justice, Gender Justice, and an Integrated Justice Approach
First, it is important to understand the basic concepts used here. The concept of (in)justice is defined as economic (mal)distribution, cultural (mis)recognition, and political (mis)representation. These injustices are shaped by agrarian structures, cultural structures (like patriarchy), and political subordination, which limit people's equal participation, particularly women's, leading to injustice. In the context of land reform and peasant struggles, justice is often a foundational demand; yet, its various dimensions are frequently overlooked, rendering gender (in)justice negligible.
Gender justice in this context means that peasant women (not solely men, as is often the case) are recognised with their right to own land independently or as co-owners with their husbands or partners in any agrarian land redistribution. This pertains to power relations, specifically between male and female peasants, with the ultimate goal of transforming it to advance gender equality and social justice in general. A just society, as conceptualised by Fraser (1999, 2005), means that people, including men and women, have equitable resources, standing, and voice. Thus, to overcome injustice means eliminating institutionalised barriers that hinder "parity of participation" in societal interactions among social classes and status orders. Fraser (2005) suggests that through parity of participation, people share in, partake of, and contribute to society by having access to the resources necessary to take an active and equal part in social interactions with others, enjoy equal social status among others, and have equal access to political decision-making. Hence, emancipation can only exist based on equal participation in all spheres of life. Consequently, I argue that pursuing gender justice on land necessitates an integrated approach that combines three spheres of land justice: economic distribution, cultural recognition, and political representation. The economic sphere of justice centres on the redistribution of resources, where class structure is the primary barrier. This aligns with the Marxian understanding of class as an economic relation between capitalists and the proletariat, focusing on exploitation and domination. In agrarian studies, this notion reveals a direct relationship between landlessness and the poverty and injustice experienced by peasants, as well as the domination and violence perpetrated by landowners. Feminist scholars linked women's landlessness to a lack of land redistribution and non-recognition of women's equal land rights. (see, for example, Agarwal 1994, Deere and Leon, 2001, Jacobs, 2013, Doss et.al, 2014, Alano 2015, Kieran et.al 2015, Levien, 2017, Morgan 2017, and Bejeno 2021).
The cultural sphere focuses on the recognition of status order, with gender relations (among other social status orders) being the main barrier. Gender injustice is produced and reproduced through patriarchy, the "institutional all-encompassing power that men have as a group over women, the systematic devaluation of all the roles and traits which the society has assigned to women" (Popkin, A., 1979). This power imbalance shapes societal practices, norms, and public policies, thereby perpetuating gender-based injustices, including land injustice. And the political sphere centers on the representation of people's voices and standing, with political structure serving as the primary barrier. Political misrepresentation, particularly in policymaking within people's organisations or state agencies, can jeopardise the advancement of marginalised or subordinated........
