Entering the high-school football stadium, Christine Wells-Wonsley and Elmore Wonsley could feel the stares.

It was late August, the first game of the season, and thousands from around Ocean Springs, Mississippi, had gathered to cheer for their boys on the city’s brightest stage. A marching band boomed. Cheerleaders danced. The public-address announcer introduced the starting lineup. Amid the spectacle, heads turned toward Wells-Wonsley and Wonsley, eyes following them up the bleachers. “No one really spoke when we walked in,” Wells-Wonsley said. “It was very surreal.”

Eight weeks earlier, on July 4, their 18-year-old son, Nolan Wells, had joined a group of friends on boats out to Horn Island, a roughly ten-mile strip of sandy wilderness where hundreds of locals gathered to swim, fish, and party. Wells never made it back home. His body was found washed up on the island two days later.

Wells had been a pillar of the Ocean Springs High School community. “He had an electric vibe to him,” said his friend Skylan Hunter, a 19-year-old who played football and basketball with Wells. “He’s always smiling. He’s real giggly.” He seemed to find friends everywhere: “You could put him with the smart kids. You could put him with the athletes. You could put Nolan with all the wannabe thugs. You put him with all the hood dudes. You put him around the band kids. He knew everybody. Everyone knew him.” A star wide receiver, Wells helped Ocean Springs win three straight district titles, scoring six touchdowns his senior season, before going off to Southwest Mississippi Community College, a two-and-a-half-hour drive inland, where he hoped to play his way to a Division I scholarship.

His parents were regulars in the bleachers at Greyhound Stadium, familiar faces in a tight-knit community, and now they returned to support Wells’s two younger brothers on the team. Those who purchased a game-day program could flip it open and see a page honoring Wells. But otherwise, nothing at the stadium indicated a beloved alumnus had recently died. There was no ceremony memorializing the tragedy that had rocked the community, no announcement recognizing Wells’s brothers, not even a moment of silence before kickoff. “There was no mention of him,” Wells-Wonsley said. “I feel like Ocean Springs as a whole wants this to just go away.”

But the questions surrounding what exactly happened to Wells on Horn Island have not gone away. The story ricocheted around social media, fueled by suspicions that his death echoed Mississippi’s history of racist violence. It sparked conversations about the safety of Black people in predominantly white spaces. The last known photo of Wells showed him sitting on a boat next to three white friends. Witnesses on the island said they last saw Wells flirting with a white woman. Ben Crump, the prominent civil-rights lawyer, signed on to represent Wells’s family. Al Sharpton spoke at his funeral. Colin Kaepernick paid for an independent autopsy. Terrell Owens and Tyler Perry contributed to the $125,000 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction in connection with Wells’s death. Within days, facts and falsehoods swirled. Online sleuths and pundits started digging. Death threats flew in every direction. Some accused Wells’s white friends of murder; others blamed Wells’s family for inflaming racial tensions without proof his death was anything but an accident.

On September 21, the district attorney’s office announced that a grand jury declined to issue any indictments for Wells’s death, stating in a report that there was “no credible evidence to support the public allegations” against the friends on the boats and that the “public attacks” against them “are malicious, false, and have no truth in fact or evidence.” In a 15-minute statement, Jackson County district attorney Angel Myers McIlrath condemned those who “have attempted to exploit Nolan’s death to divide and create chaos here.”“The family, the Crump team, and anyone close to Nolan knew his disappearance and death were not the result of racial hate or violence,” she said, “yet the flames of that narrative set against the backdrop of Mississippi’s terrible history were fanned by both people who knew the truth and those who didn’t.” Wells-Wonsley and Wonsley have held firm to their suspicions. At a news conference after the grand-jury report was released, Wells-Wonsley accused McIlrath of prioritizing a “need to get this case done and over with” at the expense of a thorough investigation. “Elmore and I do not believe Nolan simply and accidentally drowned,” said Wells-Wonsley, who, speaking through tears, concluded that “our son’s life does not matter to those who hold positions that are supposed to serve and protect the public.” McIlrath responded in a statement expressing “complete confidence” in the investigation and the grand jury’s decision and blaming Wells’s family for allowing “Nolan’s friends to be publicly accused and have their lives and their family’s lives threatened and reputations ruined.”

When I visited Ocean Springs in September, I found a city struggling to process a tragedy that has shattered the sense of racial harmony many residents take pride in. The circumstances of Wells’s death are still unclear, blocking any path to closure for a grieving family demanding answers in a place where many locals just want to move on.

“Nobody talks about it, but everybody knows about it,” Hunter said. “They talk about it everywhere else but here.”

They talk about it 150 miles up the highway in Summit, a small town surrounded by woods and farmland where Wells attended college. His SMCC football teammates bused down to the Gulf Coast for his funeral. At a team meeting discussing the tragedy, the players dedicated their season to Wells. Their helmets bear NW stickers. “He should have been here with us,” said Nero Taylor, 19, a sophomore offensive lineman. “He was gonna be a big part of it.”

As the players on Wells’s college team took the field on a hot night swarming with lovebugs, the bleachers in John I. Hurst Stadium filled with students familiar with the story. D. J. Cagins, a 19-year-old freshman from Hinds County, about a three-hour drive from Ocean Springs, said he hadn’t intended to follow the investigation but the case seemed to follow him, regularly cycling into his feed, his algorithm serving up fragmented facts and breathless opinions. It was the same for the classmates sitting around him sharing their unfounded theories.

“He was chillin’ with some girl, white dude got mad,” said freshman Jalik Trim, 19.

“They beat the shit out of that man,” said freshman Von Miles, 20. “He could’ve been a star.”

“I feel like they were jealous of him or something,” said Draco, 18.

Cagins grew up in a town where most people are Black. He could count on two hands how many white kids went to his high school. His few encounters with white folks included a traumatic memory: One evening, as he rode bikes with a couple of friends, a group of white teens in a passing pickup truck shouted the N-word at them, then turned their way and accelerated. He and his friends leaped into the bushes to escape. Only once he got to SMCC, which has around the same number of Black and white students, did Cagins find himself regularly interacting with white people.

He and his classmates began to feel wary about Wells’s death when they saw the photo of him on the boat with the white boys.

“Me personally,” Cagins said, “I wouldn’t hang out with that many white people by myself.”

“Oh, nah, that’s not happening,” Miles said. “I’m not hanging around a group of white people.”

“I got white friends, but being the only Black person? Nah,” Trim said.

But it’s different in Ocean Springs. Cagins had been to the Gulf Coast a few times for high-school football games and it felt like another world compared with where he grew up.

“You gon’ see that more down there,” Cagins said.

Down on the bayou, halfway (geographically and spiritually) between New Orleans and the Florida Panhandle, Ocean Springs has developed a distinctive reputation around the state. “Like if Mississippi had Beverly Hills,” said Taylor, who grew up in nearby Gulfport. “Basically, the place you go if you feel like you’re moving up in the world.”

In Ocean Springs, where the median income is roughly $23,000 above the state average, big brick houses sprawl across neat subdivisions along the waterfront. With waters rich in oysters, shrimp, crabs, and catfish, the Gulf Coast became home to a thriving seafood industry. Biloxi got an Air Force base, and soon casinos went up, too. Pascagoula has one of the region’s biggest ports. Ocean Springs was where people went to escape the bustle. The city’s population more than tripled from 1960 to 2000, and in the years after Hurricane Katrina, a wave of development spurred new boutique hotels, an “urban renewal” plan, and debates over gentrification.

Locals describe Ocean Springs as a good place to raise kids or retire, as it offers a suburban backdrop for fishing, shrimp boils, fireworks on the beach, and Mardi Gras celebrations — a taste of Cajun culture “but in a white sort of way,” said Noelle Nolan-Rider, an organizer with the social-justice advocacy group Mississippi Rising Coalition. She moved to Ocean Springs 11 years ago after growing up in Natchez, going to college in Baton Rouge, and living in New Orleans.........

© Daily Intelligencer