Europe Has Two Security Architectures—and Has Chosen the Wrong One
Russia has called for a new European security architecture for nearly two decades, beginning with President Putin’s Munich speech in 2007 and President Medvedev’s proposed European Security Treaty in 2008, followed by Moscow’s draft treaties of December 2021 and Putin’s call in June 2024 for indivisible security across Eurasia. The Western reply has not changed. As a British statement to the OSCE put it in June 2026, Russia keeps calling for a new security architecture, “but we already have one.”
Britain’s account is false. Europe has not one security architecture but two, built on incompatible premises. The first is the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), which includes every state from Vancouver to Vladivostok and rests on indivisible security, the principle that no state should strengthen its security at the expense of others. This is the Golden Rule applied to nations. The second is NATO, a US-led alliance premised on Western predominance and military superiority over Russia. The OSCE is an architecture of international law and mutual restraint. NATO, as it has operated since the 1990s, is an architecture of Western power, and it has brought war.
The OSCE track began with Willy Brandt’s Ostpolitik, which recognized postwar borders and renounced force. It led to the Helsinki Final Act of 1975, in which thirty-five states from East and West agreed on principles of coexistence, including non-intervention in internal affairs. German reunification was the culmination. In February 1990, Secretary of State James Baker assured Gorbachev that NATO would not move “one inch eastward,” and German leaders gave the same assurance, as declassified records show. The OSCE’s Istanbul Charter of 1999 added that no state or organization could claim pre-eminent responsibility for peace in Europe.
The NATO track ran in the opposite direction. In 1994 the Clinton administration decided to enlarge NATO despite the 1990 assurances. George Kennan called the decision “the most fateful error of American policy in the entire post-cold-war era.” NATO expanded in 1999 and again in 2004, reaching the Baltic states, and in 1999 it bombed Serbia without UN authorization. In 2008, at Bucharest, NATO declared that Ukraine and Georgia would become members, ignoring the warning of William Burns, then US ambassador in Moscow, that this was the brightest of all red lines for Russia. War in Georgia followed within months, begun by Georgia according to an EU-commissioned inquiry.
On February 21, 2014, Ukraine’s President Yanukovych signed an agreement with the opposition, witnessed by representatives of Germany, France and Poland, providing for a unity government and early elections. The next day the agreement was violently overturned. The Rada removed Yanukovych. It was an unconstitutional transfer of power, a coup, backed by Washington. Russia then annexed Crimea, in part to keep its naval base at Sevastopol out of NATO’s hands. The Minsk II agreement of 2015, designed to restore peace and endorsed by the UN Security Council, was never implemented by Ukraine, and Angela Merkel later said it had been meant to buy Ukraine time.
When Russia proposed treaties in December 2021 to end NATO’s eastward enlargement, I personally urged the White House to accept. The Biden administration refused Russia’s bid for diplomacy. After Russia invaded in February 2022, Russia and........
