“A bicycle shed is a building; Lincoln Cathedral is a piece of architecture.”

Thus begins “An Outline of European Architecture” by Sir Nikolaus Pevsner, one of the 20th century’s most celebrated architectural historians.

This quote, written in 1943, came to mind as I visited the recently completed Cragin Park Fieldhouse in the Belmont Cragin neighborhood. Designed by locally based STL Architects, the new structure raises questions about whether it might be a building or architecture.

Cragin Park is among the more modest parks under the control of the Chicago Park District. It’s small, occupying just a little less that one single city block with Drummond Place to the north, Lockwood Avenue to the west, and Wrightwood Avenue on the south. The eastern edge of the park is the north-south alley that serves businesses along Laramie. Quintessential Chicago bungalows line the north and south sides of the park, giving Cragin Park a strong sense of place rooted in this particular local building type. Its previous fieldhouse, which sat on the same site as the new building, was so modest that it made the Chicago bungalows that ring the park seem like grandiose architecture. The recently completed replacement packs considerably more architectural ambition.

The Cragin Park Fieldhouse isn’t STL’s first foray into fieldhouse design; the firm produced the well-received Williams Park Fieldhouse at 2820 S. State that opened in 2019. That building still shines as bright as a new penny in the relatively tight confines of the 8.5-acre Bronzeville park in the midst of the Dearborn Homes.

The Chicago Park District has often embraced the role of architecture in its landscapes. The history of park structures is a rich vein in Chicago’s........

© Chicago Tribune