Islam Needs Reform, and Muslims Must Be Brave Enough to Say It

I am not calling for the destruction of Islam. I am calling for its rescue from those who have turned faith into political ideology, coercion and, at its darkest extremes, a justification for violence.

That is precisely why I believe Muslims must be willing to say something that has become dangerously difficult to say in parts of our community:

Not because Islam should disappear. Not because Muslims should abandon their faith. And certainly not because Muslims are somehow incapable of living peacefully in the modern world.

Islam needs a serious intellectual and institutional reform movement because the Muslim world cannot continue allowing Islamists, authoritarian governments and self-appointed guardians of religion to decide what Islam must mean for nearly two billion people.

For too long, we have confused questioning an interpretation with questioning God.

They are not the same thing.

The Qur’an is one thing. Hadith literature is another. Medieval jurisprudence is another. Local customs are another. And the political ideology we now call Islamism is yet another.

Yet these categories are routinely collapsed into one supposedly untouchable package.

That is intellectually dishonest and increasingly dangerous.

The Hadith question cannot be forbidden

Prophet Muhammad died in 632 CE. The major canonical Sunni Hadith collections associated with scholars such as al-Bukhari and Muslim were compiled roughly two centuries later, although they drew upon earlier oral and written traditions.

That does not mean every Hadith should simply be discarded.

It means Muslims should be allowed to ask questions.

How reliable is a particular narration? What was its historical context? Does it conflict with another narration? How did early political struggles influence religious interpretation? Should every rule developed in a medieval society automatically govern human beings living more than a thousand years later?

These should not be dangerous questions.

They should be Muslim questions.

Islam developed extraordinary traditions of scholarship, debate, jurisprudence and philosophy. Yet........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)