To the Jews Who Believe It Is Only About Israel

I worry about the Jews who march under the banner “Not in My Name.”

Not because I question their sincerity.

Some have been misled.

Some are afraid of standing apart from the crowd.

I worry because I suspect they misunderstand the nature of the forces they have aligned themselves with.

Whatever the reason, they share a common assumption:

They believe the hostility is directed at Israel.

They believe it is directed at Zionists.

They believe it is not directed at them.

That assumption deserves closer examination.

Imagine, for a moment, that those accusing Israel get everything they say they want.

Do you really believe the hostility will disappear?

Do you believe the crowds chanting against Zionists will simply go home satisfied?

History offers little reason for such confidence.

The history of antisemitism is, among other things, a history of constantly changing accusations.

Jews have been condemned for refusing to assimilate.

Then for assimilating too successfully.

For living among others.

Consider the slogans.

In the 1930s, Jews across Europe often heard the same message:

“You do not belong here. Get out and go to your Palestine.”

Later,........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)