Trump versus the protesters is a false choice
It’s happening again. Violence in the streets. Protesters clashing with police. A president threatening to send in the troops.
And once again, America is being told to pick a side: Are you with “law and order” or “the resistance”? Tear gas or hashtags? Trump or chaos?
It’s a false choice — but it’s one we keep falling for.
That isn’t to say you shouldn’t pick sides in the larger culture war — or that we should fall prey to “both-sides-ism.” But when it comes specifically to what is happening right now in Los Angeles, we don’t have to choose between anarchy and authoritarianism.
A free society needs both liberty and order — rights, yes, but rights with responsibilities. Freedom with guardrails. That’s the spirit behind Edmund Burke’s idea of “ordered liberty.”
It’s a concept that demands balance. And yet here we are, again, in a moment that insists we pick one side or the other, no middle ground allowed. Today’s politics operates in binaries: for or against, red or blue, patriots or traitors.
Refusing to play this game, increasingly, is treated as moral weakness — as a cop-out. But that’s the brilliance of Burke’s formulation: It resists simplicity and mocks tribal reflexes.
Yes, the government must protect us from violent mobs. But just as surely, we must be........





















Toi Staff
Gideon Levy
Tarik Cyril Amar
Stefano Lusa
Mort Laitner
Robert Sarner
Mark Travers Ph.d
Ellen Ginsberg Simon
Andrew Silow-Carroll