The debate over the creation of new provinces in Pakistan is not a new phenomenon. However, in recent years, this issue has acquired extraordinary political significance. Alongside proposals concerning Punjab, Balochistan, and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, suggestions to divide Sindh into two or more administrative units have also surfaced from time to time. These proposals have been presented, both officially and unofficially, under various justifications such as administrative reforms, improved governance, and a more equitable distribution of resources. In the specific case of Sindh, however, the debate has extended far beyond the question of administrative efficiency. It has evolved into a fundamental issue concerning Pakistan's federal structure, the national question, the constitutional compact, provincial autonomy, and the role of the state's centres of power.

A significant segment of Sindh's political, academic, and civil society regards such proposals not merely as administrative restructuring but as a fundamental intervention in the federal compact. Their view is that altering the geographical integrity of a historic province without the explicit consent of its people would not only weaken the federal spirit embodied in the Constitution but would also seriously undermine the political trust that exists among Pakistan's diverse nationalities. The central question in this debate is whether the creation of new provinces would genuinely strengthen Pakistan's federation, or whether it would instead deepen national contradictions, intensify political mistrust, and increase tensions between the federation and the provinces. More specifically, if an attempt were made to divide Sindh, what political, constitutional, economic, and national consequences might such a step produce? Would such a measure contribute to greater stability in Pakistan, or would it ultimately weaken the very philosophical and constitutional foundations upon which the federation rests?

The concerns surrounding Sindh are particularly sensitive because Pakistan was not established as a unitary state but rather emerged as a federation formed through the partnership of historically distinct provinces, regions, and nationalities. The Lahore Resolution of 23 March 1940 envisaged autonomous federal units for the Muslim-majority regions of British India. Many constitutional scholars and political historians maintain that Punjab, Sindh, Balochistan, and the North-West Frontier Province (now Khyber Pakhtunkhwa) joined Pakistan while retaining their historical, geographical, and........

© The Friday Times