What's a Parent's Role?

Take our Authoritative Parenting Test

Find a family therapist near me

Boys often express aggression physically, while girls more often use relational aggression.

Strength becomes destructive when it is used to dominate rather than protect.

Learning to stand your ground without becoming cruel is a key step in a boy’s development.

Healthy boundaries help boys avoid becoming either bullies or victims.

Therapists sometimes use what I call a displacement story. Instead of confronting a client directly, we tell a story about someone who faced a similar situation. The client listens, recognizes something of themselves in the story, and often discovers the lesson without feeling lectured. Stories have a way of doing that as they bypass resistance and allow a person to see themselves from a different angle. In many ways, it is a version of Archetypal Psychology.

I was reminded of this recently when a client told me about a call he received from his son’s school. The principal had asked him to come in because his son had been involved in a fight. When the father arrived, the boy was sitting in the chair outside the office. He took his son’s hand and went into the principal's office. The principal explained that his son had gotten into a physical confrontation with two other boys in the hallway. “We have a strict no-aggression policy,” she told him. The punishment, she explained, would be three days of suspension.

The father listened carefully and then asked what had happened. The principal explained that the other boys had been pushing and bothering his son for several days. That afternoon things escalated, and his son finally fought back.

The father smiled and told the principal that he had been talking with his son about something very similar recently. He had been trying to teach the boy an important distinction, one that many boys have to learn as they grow up.

The difference between being a bully and standing your ground.

The father explained that his son loved superhero movies. Like many boys his age, he spent hours in his room acting out stories with action figures and imaginary battles between heroes and villains. One evening, the father noticed something interesting. Whenever he overheard his son playing, the boy played as the villain more than the hero. The villain was powerful, aggressive, and feared. The hero, by contrast, often had to endure suffering and struggle before ultimately winning. So, the father decided to talk with him about it.

He told the boy something that may seem simple but is psychologically profound. The hero and the villain actually begin in the same place. Both were hurt at some point in their lives. Both experienced something unfair, painful, or humiliating.

The villain decides that because he was hurt, he will hurt others. The hero decides that because he was hurt, he will make sure others are not hurt the same way. The father told his son that being strong is not the problem. The real question is what a person decides to do with it. A bully uses strength to dominate others. A protector uses strength to prevent harm.

At the same time, the father told him something equally important. Do not become a doormat. Set boundaries for yourself, and with others, but that doesn’t mean becoming a hammer looking for nails everywhere.

If someone says something unkind, sometimes the wisest way to handle it is to ignore it. Words alone are not always worth a battle. But if someone repeatedly crosses a line, if they begin pushing, shoving, or physically intimidating, then standing your ground may be necessary. Children, especially boys, often learn boundaries in ways that adults sometimes misunderstand.

This was the moment the conversation with the principal shifted. The principal repeated that the school maintained a “no aggression” policy. The father understood the intention behind the rule. Schools are trying to reduce violence and create safe environments. That goal is admirable and necessary. There was something the principal was missing with the idea that all forms of aggression should be treated the same.

What's a Parent's Role?

Take our Authoritative Parenting Test

Find a family therapist near me

Psychologists have observed for many years that boys and girls often express aggression differently. Developmental psychologists sometimes distinguish between physical aggression and relational aggression. Both appear early in childhood, but they tend to follow different social pathways as boys and girls grow. Boys’ aggression tends to be overt. It is physical, visible, and direct. Two boys may shove each other in the hallway, exchange a punch or two, and five minutes later sit in the same classroom as if nothing had happened. Personally, some of my closest friendships were formed this way a long time ago.

Girls’ aggression often follows a different path. Psychologists sometimes call it relational aggression. Instead of fists, the weapons are social. Gossip, rumor, backstabbing, innuendo, exclusion, subtle alliances, and quiet character attacks that can spread through a group in ways that are difficult for adults to detect and even harder for a child to defend against. The injury is not to the body but to reputation and belonging, and those wounds can linger for months or even years.

Both forms of aggression can be harmful. The difference is that one is obvious and short-lived, while the other is often hidden and lasts much longer.

The father tried to explain this with a simple image. He said that years earlier, he had lived in a housing complex where he walked his dog every evening. Each night, they passed the same yard where another dog lived. The moment the dogs saw each other, they started barking at each other. Both animals acted as if they were mortal enemies. For thirty seconds, it was a barking war.

But the moment they turned the corner and the other dog disappeared from sight, the tension vanished. His dog went right back to sniffing the grass as if nothing had happened. The conflict had burned itself out almost instantly.

In many ways, boys’ aggression can work the same way. It erupts quickly, expresses itself directly, and then dissipates just as quickly. This does not mean aggression should be encouraged or celebrated. It does mean that eliminating every form of confrontation may also eliminate a natural way boys learn to establish boundaries.

The goal is not to raise boys who are aggressive. The goal is to raise boys who understand the difference between cruelty and courage.

A bully seeks domination. A protector seeks balance.

The father explained to the principal that he had been trying to teach his son precisely that difference. The boy was not trying to intimidate others. In fact, he had tolerated the two other boys’ behavior for several days before finally responding.

As the meeting ended, the father and his son walked out of the principal’s office together. The principal was doing what was right, trying to keep the school peaceful and safe. The father understood that. But as he walked down the hallway with his son beside him, he realized something important had happened. The boy had crossed a small but necessary threshold. For the first time, he had discovered that he did not have to live as either a bully or a victim. There was a third path—standing up for himself without becoming cruel.

The father told me something interesting. He said the most important lesson that day had nothing to do with school discipline. Instead, what mattered most was that his son had begun to understand something fundamentally important about strength.

Strength is not measured by how easily you hurt someone. Strength is measured by whether you can carry power without becoming cruel. That is the real challenge boys face as they grow into men.

Not just learning how to fight. But learning when not to.

© Psychology Today